Saturday, November 21, 2026

WE GOT HOODWINKED

The summer between my freshman and sophomore year of college, I dedicated myself to one task: to get abs.  I had become infatuated with fitness prior to that, having grown up a fat kid until the age of 14, wherein, through willpower, exercise and starvation, I managed to shed 25lbs of fluff and look like a normalish kid, and through some weight training and access to a college meal plan I managed to put on enough muscle that, when I came back to visit my high school that year, my band teacher looked at me and said “You grew shoulders!”  But I still had this unimpressive flat but formless stomach, and I knew that ALL impressive physiques began with a set of abs.  Well, willpower and exercise worked before: it was BOUND to work again.  I knew that, to get abs, I had to lose fat, and I KNEW that exercise burned fat, so that’s what I decided to do.  I had a light work schedule with a part-time summer job at a Sporting Goods store, so with all the freetime in the world, I ran 16 miles a day: 8 first thing in the morning (because fasted cardio burns fat of course) and 8 later in the afternoon, with weight training in between.  And after 3 months of this protocol, I had successfully obtained…a stress fracture in my foot, with the same formless stomach I started with.  Why?  Maybe it was because, after running 16 miles a day every day, I was ravenous, and would house Costco giant cookies and brownie bites immediately post run, and would use my half hour lunch break at work to eat the 1lb “Double 6-dollar burger” at Carl’s Jr across the street (lettuce wrapped, of course, for the low carbs…to balance out those cookies).  Meanwhile, later that same year, while IN college, being unable to run 16 miles a day and only able to lift weights 3-4x a week due to my academic demands, someone snapped a photo of me shirtless and I discovered that, unbeknownst to me, I had developed a case of abs.  Why?  Maybe it was because I was on a meal plan, and could only eat when I was IN the college cafeteria, instead of being surrounded by food like when I was home for the summer, and maybe it was because most of the food was so unpleasant that I gravitated toward the meat and eggs and wasn’t eating so many damn sweets…maybe because I wasn’t so damn hungry in the first place from not running 16 miles a day, every day.  And with that incredibly long story serving as my introduction, allow me to continue to pontificate on the reality that we, as a people, have been hoodwinked to believe that EXERCISE is the answer to our physique woes, and just how detrimental this thought process has been to us.


Surely it was those pesky BUNS that were holding me back!


 

The notion that “exercise will save us” is pervasive across our culture.  Think back to movie montages of transforming from zero to hero, going back to the classics of the Rocky movies to the Disney Hercules film to just so many other wonderful options.  And consider that we had a television show titled “The Biggest Loser” which prominently featured multiple hour long workout sessions promoting the notion that THIS was what it took to lose weight and change our lives.  We “know” as a people that, with enough hard work, we can rapidly and radically transform and overhaul our bodies and, in turn, our destinies: no longer a victim of circumstance.  We’ve taken charge of our fate: we ARE in control!

 

And that’s the great con of it all.  We got sold the narrative that exercise would save us, because exercise is fast AND it can be packaged, sold and marketed.  8 minute abs, sweating to the oldies, Crossfit, etc etc: everyone found a way to get their fingers in the pie and be able to sell you the means of salvation.  And THEN they also made sure to make exercise SEEM complicated, so that you needed to be saved from it by seeking out their assistance…and a nominal fee of course.  But the reason WHY this con got sold to us is because we WANTED it to get sold to us.  We WANTED this delusion, we WANTED to get hoodwinked.  Why?  Because the truth was so horrible that we’d rather buy a pretty lie.


Kinda like when we tried to convince ourselves that we actually enjoyed this movie

 


Because the truth is, there is no rapid course correction.  The body is a ship, and it is SLOW to turn once it is set on a course.  And, quite often, the harder you try to force it to change, the LONGER the process takes, because biology and reality is cruel and has no concern for our short attention spans.  Our physiques are NOT a reflection of our most recent exercise program: they’re the reflection of the accumulation of our LIFETIME of decisions: for good or for ill.  And when you think about it, how much time do you spend exercising, vs how much time do you spend NOT exercising?  Of those 2, which do you feel is going to have the more significant contributing factor?  Yeah, we wanna believe that 1-2 hours a day, 3-6 days per week is going to be the key to achieving that movie star physique (pay particular attention to that wide range of time I put there, because folks are operating under the premise that the missing variable is that they “only” exercise 3 days per week for an hour, and if they cranked it up to 6 for 2 hours, they’d REALLY be getting somewhere), but if we’re housing Costco cookies, stressed out from work, sleeping poorly, putting junk in our bodies, etc, during that NON-exercise time, guess which direction the ship is going to head toward.  And if we try to UNDO all of that damage with MORE training, all we do is up the stressors on the body even MORESO and just cause even more damage to it.

 

But we WANT to be hoodwinked, because how awful of an idea is it that, in order to be physically great, we have to LIVE physical greatness?  And how awful is it that living this greatness is NOT going to look like an Animal-pak advert, where we painfully munch on plain chicken and white rice while staring into the abyss and contemplating the meaninglessness of it all.  Bodybuilding prep diets are STILL missing the point of this, because THAT is a short term intense intervention akin to the training montage we spoke about earlier: it’s not sustainable, it’s effects are ephemeral, and the AFTER effects could very well be irreversible, if not at least MORE damaging than the initial state we began the whole process in.  Observe how many Biggest Loser contestants put on MORE weight than what they lost on the show, while being in a worse metabolic state because they shed a bunch of lean tissue and put back on a bunch of fat mass.      


Yet the calves remained the same size


Folks, exercise is awesome.  It improves nutrient partitioning & cardiorespiratory health, builds muscle, strength, balance, flexibility and mobility, but it DOES all this under the assumption that we have EVERYTHING ELSE dialed in properly.  Exercise ENHANCES a lifestyle geared toward self-improved: it is not THE lifestyle itself.  Much like how Captain Crunch is part of a balanced breakfast, exercise is part of a balanced lifestyle, and much like how those kids (or adults) just pouring themselves a bow of Captain Crunch and eating it WITHOUT the eggs, milk, yogurt and meat to alongside it, those who seek exercise as their fitness intervention salvation can, quite often, put themselves in a worse state than where they began.  In our attempts to “work ourselves back into shape”, we can just run ourselves into the ground, not having the appropriate recovery mechanisms in place to be able to actually benefit from all the damn exercise we’re doing in an attempt to transform ourselves.  Exercise is not the tool to lose fat or to build muscle: it’s the tool to ENHANCE the processes already put in place to facilitate these outcomes. 

No comments:

Post a Comment