In the past,
I have written of “the tyranny of freedom”, and today I come to argue the other
side of the equation in the freedom OF limitations. Yes, once again I must clarify that, despite
my propensity for typos due to the nature of how I write, I do in fact mean
freedom OF limitations rather than from.
What, specifically, I mean to discuss in the fact that, in truth, it is
the granting of limitations that ultimately give many trainees the freedom they
so desperately crave in their training.
Oftentimes, trainees find themselves paralyzed and hamstrung due to the
absence of limitations in their training, for without limitation they are given
such absurd degree of freedom of choice that they feel a complete inability to
make any decision and commit to any action.
Ultimately, these trainees feel compelled to make the BEST decision when
given no limitations, and in their attempt to discover the best decision, they
find they cannot make any decision.
Enter limitations.
They're telling you to keep calm when there are no limits because you SHOULD be panicking
Once limitations
enter the decision making matrix, suddenly the trainee has MUCH more freedom,
for now they’ve been obviated of the obligation to make the best decision. They must NOW, instead, make the best
decision for right NOW. We’ve gone from
Plato’s forms to Machiavelli’s realism, and the latter is FAR more easier to
operate within than the former. Once
there are a few hardset rules of engagement that one MUST operate within,
certain elements are removed from the table and we must instead work with what
we have. Sometimes this occurs in the
realm of injury removing certain movements from our training, sometimes it’s a
time constraint, sometimes it’s an equipment constraint, etc etc, but no matter
what the situation, SOMETHING forces the training to adapt and overcome in
their planning.
And this is,
in turn, where we experience so MUCH freedom, because now we are freed from the
yoke of having to make the absolute BEST decision. Instead of “how do I build the best program”
it’s “how do I build the best program WITHOUT bending my knee” or “with ONLY
225lbs of weight” or “with ONLY 1 hour of training time”. These massive, wide-swath cutting
restrictions force the trainee into making decisions to operate the best within
a certain paradigm, and from here, decisions are far easier to make. No longer is it about making the best
decisions in total, but simply the best decisions for that moment in time.
Like maybe deciding not to show up for the fight...
This is the
BLESSING of limitations, yet so many trainees lament them as a curse. How bizarre.
And fundamentally, it boils down to a complete unwillingness to alter
one’s approach and one’s thinking. How
many times have you seen a trainee in a ridiculously overstocked gym only to go
“My gym doesn’t have a reverse hyper.
HOW am I going to run conjugate now?!”
Or they complain about how they only have an hour to train, or only 3
days a week to train, or are injured, or only have so much weight available,
etc etc. Here they are, being granted
freedom from the responsibility of training the absolute BEST, and they
complain. They wallow in misery and
defeat, rather than maximizing the blessing of being able to train
creatively. NOW is your chance to have
real freedom.
But why wait
until you are FORCED into these limitations?
Why not enforce these limitations upon yourself in absence of external
forces? This, once again, IS the freedom
that you enjoy as an autonomous being.
You don’t need to wait until you are injured or constrained in order to
enjoy the freedom of limitations. When
designing your training, from the outset decide ahead of time on what your
limitations will be and let that shape your training. You
need no other reason for these limitations other than “I have decided these are
the limitations of the training”.
"My training is ONLY going to be ineffective"
In turn, own
these limitations once decided. Often I
am asked “Why don’t you train THIS way” when one views my training, and I
answer honestly that it’s one of my self-imposed limitations. The most obvious one is the limitation of
time. I budget an hour 4 times a week to
lift weights, and 30-60 minutes once a week for conditioning. For me, that is how much I will allow myself
to train. With that limitation, I am
forced to be efficient with my exercise selection, and if I want to get in more
volume, I have to find ways to ensure that I can get it done WITHIN that
time. This means making the most out of
super and giant sets and short rest periods.
And in turn, now I am driven to start training FOR my training. If I’m going to be doing supersets and giant
sets and having short rest periods, I better have solid conditioning, or else
the whole plan is going to fall apart.
How am I going to improve my conditioning? Well let’s look at my limitations and let
that decide how my programming will unfold.
You can
observe how the mere addition of just ONE limitation works as the catalyst for
further decision making, and has a domino effect that makes the entire training
plan unfold. Whereas before we stared
out into a vast abyss of endless decision making potentials, each with a series
of known and unknown consequences, we instead immediately shut off a whole
spectrum of potential realities and vectored ourselves toward SOME sort of
outcome. Because, fundamentally, A
decision is always better than no decision.
Make your decision to have limits and, in doing so, grant yourself some
freedom.
I'll add one for the limitations I wish I had imposed on myself sooner. I don't have much money in my post-relocation life. What money we do have after living expenses goes toward home improvements. It doesn't make sense to spend money on lifting books, ebooks, equipment, when I need food, tools, and things to keep me warm through the winter. As a result, my limitation is that I already have all the knowledge and equipment that I need to get big and strong, which has already been extremely liberating, and coming into my contest next weekend I'm hitting some of my heaviest lifts in recent years. No more searching for the missing piece of equipment or knowledge, just finding ways to get more out of the abundance I already have. How much was I buying and intaking before without actually using, just because I could, let alone the question of was that intake actually serving to hold me back?
ReplyDeleteWR
That is so much better of a point than what I made in the post I wish I wrote THAT instead, haha. Very solid point indeed. I remember reaching a similar point after buying an unsatisfying book on training and eventually realizing I had learned enough. Probably one of the least satisfying parts about this activity is the day you realize that it's pretty much just a question of time and compliance.
DeleteI still want to read the new CNP book, but between the strapped finances and not being able to stomach the irony of buying a book to tell me that I don't need books to learn how to train, that's $50 I'll put to other uses for now.
DeleteLeast satisfying? Or liberating? Reads similarly to what you write to novices overwhelmed by all the program choices/options. Just means there's many viable paths assuming you put in good effort and enough time.
WR
Liberating AND unsatisfying, haha. Like getting graded on attendance: you know what you need to do, but doing it is tedious.
DeleteWhat I got out of those two articles (The Freedom of Limitations and The Tyranny of Freedom) is the difference between trying to identify limitations beyond our control and those within our control. Trying to identify limitations beyond our control seems to focus on outsourcing responsibility for our failures (trying to pin down genetic limit or how many times a week are necessary to get stronger, etc) and comes back to your question somewhere of "what are you going to do with that information?". Identifying or applying limitations within our control seems to be more about empowering the lifter. E.g. I can/will only dedicate these resources to getting stronger and I AM going to get stronger. I just flicked through 5/3/1 again to clarify some things and on the 2 days a week page Wendler says thinking you can't get stronger lifting twice a week is a piss poor excuse. I liked that.
ReplyDeleteHeads up, you have a spam comment link on The Tyranny of Freedom article that probably needs deleting: https://mythicalstrength.blogspot.com/2018/06/tyranny-of-freedom.html
This one was an excellent piece! Thank you.
ReplyDeleteThanks dude!
Delete