I am by no means a nutrition guy. I eat a low carb diet because it’s one less
thing to think about, I’ve never counted a calorie or a macro in my life minus
1 day in 2004 when I started my training log, and I found the whole experience so
off-putting I never tried again. I
really don’t think it’s all that complicated, yet I constantly have trainees
asking me to explain to them the idea of “eat to recover from your training.” That is ALWAYS the advice I offer when it
comes to nutrition: your food supports your training, so you need to eat in a
manner where you are recovering from training.
Inevitably, the brain of the person asking the question starts going to
the realm of macro counting, and they ask me if I mean to eat so that they’re
gaining 1-2lbs a week, or eat for maintenance, or something else entirely. Folks: that’s a WEIRD question to ask in the
context of the conversation. Food is
recovery: just like sleep, yet somehow folks completely understand how to sleep
and have no idea how to eat. Allow me to
demonstrate…
Some of you already have this figured out
Some of you already have this figured out
Let’s say you and I have a big day planned tomorrow. It’s winter, in North Dakota, so we know that
the first thing we’re gonna need to do is shovel snow for 2 hours so that we
can get our car out of the driveway, and then we’re gonna drive to a strongman
competition, compete all day and drive back home that same day so that we can
beat the winter storm that will inevitably follow us home and snow us in
again. I tell you in the evening: “Hey,
we got a big day tomorrow: make sure you get enough sleep.” How come that’s ALL I need to say to you in
order for you to understand intent? Why
is it that when I say “get enough sleep to perform” you know that means you
probably need to get to bed an hour earlier than you usually do? You’re not asking me dumb questions like “Do
you mean get enough sleep that my eyes aren’t red when I wake up in the
morning? Or should it be that I get
enough sleep that I wake up naturally on my own and don’t need an alarm clock?” No, somehow, when I say “sleep enough that
you are recovered from today and ready to perform for tomorrow”, you know what
you need to do, but when I say “eat enough that you are recovered from today
and ready for tomorrow”, you’re helpless.
It’s ALL just recovery.
And it’s the same thing when it comes to QUALITY of recovery.
Same exact scenario, I tell you to get
enough sleep for tomorrow, you KNOW that what you need to do is get to a bed in
a dark room and try to get some solid, unbroken, restful sleep. You won’t try and do something stupid like
take a 1 hour nap on the couch with the TV on, wake up, hang around for 20
minutes, then go sleep on the floor for 2 hours with the lights on and dogs
barking, then figure you’ll grab a nap on the car ride to the comp and that should
be good. We KNOW that quality sleep is
important ALONG with quantity sleep, but when it comes to nutrition? We have “If It Fits Your Macros”, the “car
nap” of nutrition: collecting macros from anywhere just like getting your hours
of sleep at any time. We have folks that
have memorized the amount of carbs in a large McDonald’s French fry yet have no
idea what Vitamin A does. We have folks
that have convinced themselves that fast food and TV dinners are the superior
choice because they are mega high in sodium and “salt is good for lifters bro”,
not recognizing the terrible quality of food they’re putting into their
bodies. Yet again, I tell you to sleep
to support your training and it makes total sense, but when it comes to eat to
support your training…
Yup
Yup
The real kicker out of all of this is that I’m the first to
say that sleep isn’t that important for recovery: at least, not compared to
food. Folks, if sleep was the most
important part about getting big and strong, I woulda been a world record
holder at age 17, but I slept a LOT as a teenager. I slept like a baby, multiple double hour
sleep sessions a day, ESPECIALLY in the summer, when I had no real
obligations. My body was PRIMED for
recovery: but my nutrition was crap. Not
enough food, and what I did eat wasn’t very good. I’m in my 30s now, and I continue to grow
bigger and stronger every year, despite the fact I’ve been sleeping less, and
the sleep I get tends to be erratic and broken.
It’s a byproduct of children/pets, being a light sleeper who tends to
react to both of those things when needed, and a weird work schedule that
forces my sleep to adapt. But my
nutrition has improved substantially.
For one, I learned how to cook, and can make enough quality food that I’m
never forced into a situation where I have to eat something awful for me “for
the macros”. I’ll indulge in fast food
or eating out, but that’s the thing: I acknowledge it’s an indulgence. I understand I’m getting a “car nap” of nutrition
out of it, but in turn, it’s not a permanent fixture of my lifestyle. I’ve experimented with both, and folks, given
a choice between an abundance of good quality sleep with awful nutrition vs
awful sleep with an abundance of good quality nutrition, the latter absolutely
wins, hands down, at least insofar as getting bigger and stronger goes. In fact, in a true bout of “proof of concept”,
the IDEA for this blogpost came to me as I was driving home at 3:00 AM, with an
alarm set to get up at 6:15 to walk my kid to school so I could get back to bed
by 7:30 and get another 3 hour nap before starting my day and training at
12:30.
So take this metaphor to heart and uncomplicate how you
eat. When you hear “eat to support your
training”, think of it as no different than how you would sleep. If you have an average training block ahead
of you, feel free to eat averagely. If
you have light training, eat lightly.
But if you’re entering a training block that is going to be intense, and
call upon your reserves, you’re going to need to eat in a way to support that
training.
Sweet dreams.
What a great article! Really made a lot of things "click".
ReplyDeleteAwesome dude. It was a definite "ah hah" for me as it came to me.
DeleteThis is a great comparison and really ties together some of the other things you've said about diet. You've changed how I think about diet because (as silly as it sounds) you're the first person who I've seen recommend eating according to how you workout. Most things out there give the impression of a separation between the two. If you want to bulk then you workout and eat at a caloric surplus; if you want to cut then you workout and eat at a caloric deficit. Your blog posts are the only place so far I've seen it recommended to up volume when eating at a surplus and then cut volume when cutting food (rather than vice versa!). Once it's been pointed out in those obvious terms it is clear that that's the implication in something like 5/3/1 BBB where Wendler says not to do it on a deficit. The understanding you've helped me reach is that how much I need to eat is determined by my work capacity which is actually pretty easy to understand.
ReplyDeleteGlad it's been helpful dude. I had to go through the same revelation myself before I could start writing about it. So many people want to divorce training and nutrition when it's such a balanced relationship. They have to make sense together.
DeleteHopefully it catches on, haha.
It has helped me in another way too which is something I hadn't thought about before your writings. Whether I should be thinking about cutting some weight is primarily determined by my current conditioning level as I am most concerned about my ability to train BJJ and get in some useful strength training. Currently, I am not in decent enough condition to do what I consider to be minimal viable training on and off the mats. So the first objective is to hit enough weekly volume that I have the option to cut back to an amount I am happy with. The interconnection between nutrition and training you discuss so far is the most useful metric for me to tell me when I should be (or perhaps in better words, can justify) eating at a surplus or deficit.
DeleteHave you had your dog checked for diabetes? Friend of mine has a schnauzer that was waking them up multiple times a night, turned out it was that.
ReplyDeleteIt's not waking me up to pee: it's just lonely. It wants in the bed, then it wants to change positions in the bed.
DeleteAh... my friend has a cat like that. Condolences.
DeleteSuch a great way of looking at it, at least for those with good instincts, self control and common sense.
ReplyDeleteThanks man. My hope is that this will actually remove the instincts portion of it. Sleep is so instinctual to us, and eating SHOULD be that way too: we just overcomplicate it. The abundance of resources confounds things too, but at the same time, I'm not writing about minimizing fat. That comes from experimenting. Once you're recovering from training, if you find you're getting too fat, you can start stripping AWAY food until you aren't recovering, and then you've found your baseline.
DeleteReally enjoyed this. I'm a "Low-arber" too, just because I am able to convince myself to eat more veggies that way, rather defaulting to complex carbs and protein EVERY MEAL 😂. (Not the worst thing but not necessary in my case)
ReplyDeleteGreat read!
Glad you appreciated it dude. This post ended up generating some churn online from a few folks that felt it made things a bit too simplistic, but that's kinda the point, haha. Awesome you could appreciate it.
Delete