Here’s some good old-fashioned ranting. Despite writing this blog for over a decade, despite being online for 22 years (god how did I get so old), despite lifting weights for 24 years, despite wanting to be big and strong being one of my earliest cognizant thoughts, I STILL find myself baffled by some of the things I see trainee concern themselves with. I apologize for writing such a ridiculously long sentence and ending it with a preposition: it appears all my time spent writing did not actually make me a better writer. By grammatical self-callout aside: seriously…are you serious?! Are you genuinely concerned about these things? Do you really have such little self-awareness that you don’t see the patent absurdity in your concern? To what do I refer?
“Are
deadlifts safe?” You’re really,
genuinely wondering that? Think about
WHERE you are coming from when you ask that question. You’ve been plastered to a couch eating
cheesepuffs for a few decades, decided that you’re going to “make a change”,
pirated a copy of Starting Strength (and honestly, these days, I’d be proud of
you for at least READING A BOOK on training, but most likely you just watched a
Tik Tok), saw a photo of a deadlift and immediately freaked out and went online
trying to find some way to save yourself from this demonlift. There’s no WAY a deadlift could be safe,
right? It’s got “dead” in the name for
goodness sake! You’re not supposed to
lift with your back: everyone knows that!
Wanna know
what’s more dangerous than deadlifting?
Sitting on a couch eating cheesepuffs!
We are a society that is DYING from obesity and a sedentary lifestyle. You were LANGUISHING while you “exercised”
the luxury of bingewatching an entire television series a night for weeks on
end. That these are referred to as
“marathon” sessions is true irony. This
was an OBJECTIVELY dangerous activity you engaged in, and you did it with such
regularity and never ONCE asked “is this safe?”
But now, NOW that we are in pursuit of physical transformation, in
pursuit of improvement, in pursuit of change, NOW is when you start to ask “is
this safe?” Deadlifting is OBJECTIVELY
safer than NOT deadlifting, because when you NOT deadlift, what you do instead
is glue yourself to the couch and accelerate your morbidity.
And, of
course, I extend this to all the ridiculous questions about safety. Failing a squat? “But I saw someone die from that!” How many people have you seen die from a
sedentary lifestyle and poor eating habits?
Yet, again: no one is asking “is that safe?!” No one bats an eye when someone comes into
work on Monday and reports “I watched the entire ‘Game of Thrones’ series from
Friday through Sunday”, or “I spent 18 hours playing Call of Duty” (you can
tell by the age of my references that I’m completely unaware of what’s actually
popular these days). Hell, often these
“feats” are celebrated! But that same
dude coming in and pulling up a video of them getting after it on some
deadlifts will have all manner of tongue clucking saying “My back hurt just
watching that!” “Be careful!” “Lower the weight and focus on form!” “THAT’S NOT
SAFE!” Is the good morning safe? Bruce Lee broke his back doing that! Are you serious?! Any trainee who is concerned about
accidentally replicating the feats of Bruce Lee after a lifetime of being
sedentary is living a world of fabulous delusions of grandeur.
“Is it safe
to eat 6 eggs a day?” Are you
serious?! You ask THIS question
NOW? Did you ask if it was safe to eat
brightly colored corn powder pellets that came out of a cardboard box with a
cartoon character on it that has a shelflife that can be measured in halfyear
intervals? Did you ask if it was safe
when you were drinking a carbonated and caffeinated beverage that came in
colors that flat out do not exist on this Earth? Did you ask it if was safe when you ate a
Poptart, Zebracake, Twinkie, donut, cupcake, etc? When you ate the “death by chocolate”
cake? It’s literally called “death by
chocolate!” But now, NOW you’re going to
ask me if AN EGG is safe to eat? If this
food that has been around BEFORE humans have, this food that has nourished
countless other species, this food that is one ingredient vs a chemistry
thesis, this food that is vitamin and nutrient rich…you’re going to wonder if
THIS is the food that’s going to kill you?
Are you serious?! And again: this
is just about eggs. We see this question
about eating “too much” red meat. Hey,
wanna guess how much Captain Crunch is “too much?” It’s less than 1 serving. Find me someone that has only ever eaten eggs
and red meat and never touched a bowl of kid’s breakfast cereal and I assure
you that you’ll find a MUCH healthier human than any random “normal” person
walking around out there, living a “safe” existence.
I was legit looking for parody cereals but discovered this real one which SHOULD be a joke...
You’ve
become so conditioned to accept REAL danger as “normal” that when you
experience true safety you immediately point and scream “danger!” simply
because it’s DIFFERENT. And what a sad
state of decline you experience in your existence wherein being physically
active and eating a natural diet is what’s seen as “alien” while slumping onto
a couch, having a streaming serving overload your senses with lights, colors,
sounds and images while you mindlessly shovel processed non-food into your face
is “safe”. Prior to the moment you
decided to pursue physical transformation, you NEVER concerned yourself with
the safety of your decisions: why choose NOW to ONLY engage in 100% safe
approaches to anything? Whatever risk
you put yourself in by deadlifting, squatting, doing loaded carries, swinging a
kettlebell, doing cleans, eating eggs, steak, bacon, butter, fasting, etc etc,
is STILL significantly improving your overall safety compared to assuming a
sedentary lifestyle with the current standard approach to eating that everyone
else is engaged in. You will so
positively improve your safety FROM taking these “risks” that your rate of
all-cause morbidity will precipitously decline, simply because you made A
change away from one of the most dangerous lifestyles there is: the average
one.
Are you
serious?! If you’re serious about BEING
serious, then, seriously…take the risk.
Hi, first time long time. This one really spoke to me because of a conversation I had with a coworker yesterday. He was bemoaning how he feels like crap all the time and needs to work out and was asking me what I do (super squats currently). We start talking about lifting and conditioning and nutrition and how to make time for all of that--get up at 5am to lift, run sprints for 20 minutes after work--and he starts talking about how it's "impossible" and I'm crazy to do all that. I get that it's hard to find the motivation for some people and that being active my whole life makes it easier, but if I can invest maybe 6 hours of my time every week and commit to eating real food, and I feel healthy, strong, and energetic, while me coworker feels tired and weak all the time, who is the crazy one? What is impossible is that people want to sit on the couch all the time and eat sugar and also expect to feel healthy. It doesn't work like that.
ReplyDeleteAnyways thank you for writing those every week. I've read every post since discovering the blog about a year ago and it has been a great source of inspiration and ideas.
Dude, that means SO much that you've read so much of what I've written: thanks for that! And that exchange you had is far too common. "I'll do anything to look and feel better...except try". And it takes SO little trying to make an impact. Sure: more is better, but a little goes a long way.
DeleteI am curious what the impact of someone with little or no training experience is when they start casually going to the gym for the first time. I suspect that they get discouraged and quit because they don't know how to work hard enough to see a difference that is actually motivating. I played sports constantly from age 5 through high school and I was a pretty serious distance runner for a long time afterwards before I started lifting, so there's really never been I time where I wasn't doing some kind of training. The motivation is easy because it is a habit and I know I won't feel good if I don't do something physical every day. But I didn't really start to see big changes in my physique until I started adding conditioning and strip sets above what the program called for when doing 5/3/1 and doing programs like Super Squats and Deep Water that really push you hard. I feel as though taking those extra steps and really going all out is what truly gets the results that people want when they start going to the gym, but most people don't know how to push themselves that hard and end up being dissatisfied. They don't know how to "get to yes."
DeleteThat's such a big part of it, and people get SO mad at me when I say that, before lifting, they need to play a sport. But it's true, for all those reasons you just mentioned. You learn SO much out there on the playing field that you can't replicate in the gym.
DeleteI have a Pop Warner football field at the end of my street and one of my typical conditioning workouts is to go there and run 16-20 110 yard sprints. It sucks, but I did that in full pads after two-a-day practices when I was a teenager so I know I can do it. Someone who never had to run gassers or do burpees after a practice has no idea.
DeleteModern society has no idea on the concept of good in terms of health
ReplyDeleteI love your username dude! And absolutely true: we're so far off base on what could possibly be healthy. So much of that is we rely on entertainment for education.
DeleteI always feel motivated to train after reading your blog.
ReplyDeleteThe problem is the amount of information on youtube. An expert like Doug Brignole claimed that squats, deadlifts and pull ups are inherently dangerous. Even strongman Robert Oberst states that the deadlift is not worth the risk.
What would you advice for example a construction or warehouse worker who is on his feet all day long?
This person might be afraid of injuries which affect his ability to work and generate an income.
Maybe I see to many obstacles and I should overcome that injury mentality.
Really appreciate you swinging by David.
DeleteThe big thing about the abundance of information is we need to interpret that to mean there are so many ways to SUCCEED in this endeavor: not that there are so many pitfalls. For every Doug Brignole out there we also have equal amounts of dudes succeeding with the methods. And along with that, we have to look at how these folks ARRIVED at a point where they reached these conclusions. Yeah: Dorian Yates may not have squatted or deadlifted as an olympia champion, but on the way there? We have to EARN these rights.
I've met Rob Oberst. He was at my 3rd strongman competition, and I got a photo with him and Nick Best. We got to chat a little and he's an awesome dude. And unfortunately, his quote on that interview got taken SO far out of context. Rob was talking about THE deadlift: not deadlifting in general, because in strongman we will clarify when a deadlift is a different than standard deadlift (13" deadlift, axle deadlift, tire deadlift, etc). And I wholly agree with Rob: THE deadlift is just stupid, primarily because the starting position of it is arbitrarily determined by the diameter of weight plates. That's not going to be the ideal starting position for the vast majority of trainees. Unless your goal is powerlifting, it's better to find YOUR deadlift than to try to conform your body to the bar.
I'd never advice a construction/warehouse worker, or any human for that matter. I'm not a coach, and it'd be wholly irresponsible for me to advise anyone other than myself on matters of training. But for myself, the biggest things I'd do for injury prevention is learn how to brace and learn how to hinge at the hips before I do any sort of heavy compound movements.
Oberst doesn't seem to imply "find your deadlift height." He appears to say "do hang clean and power clean instead. All athletes who know what they're doing do hang cleans and power cleans rather than deadlifts."
DeleteWhich I think is a good choice compared to THE deadlift for sure. In the context of his dialog I agree. I find it harder for an athlete to get hurt on a clean compared to the deadlift simply because technique will limit load.
DeleteHang cleans and power cleans are fine but I'm confused where he's coming from in saying that all professional non-Strongman/Powerlifting athletes are only hang cleaning and power cleaning. Pretty easy to disprove but it's a powerful claim that will fool people who don't know better. And when Oberst became aware his talk had caused controversy his only response was to start selling a deadlifting t-shirt
DeleteI have a feeling there is nothing I can say here that will change things, haha.
DeleteSo, i used to unload trucks at walmart. Physical labor 8 hours a day and sometimes rather strenuous. I still went to the gym afterwards.
DeleteMy advicre, based solely on personal experience, would be to use the job as conditioning and focus on strength wjen in the gym, amd be glad youre in a position where you get paid to be fit.
The people at real risk of killing thenselves are the ones who sit behind a desk. They need extra time in the gym to undo sittong down for 8 hours a day, and for conditioning, and strength. When i unloaded trucks i could do squat, bench, deadlidt, that was it, and be ok.
Now? I have to mess with all the auxillary lifts also.
Thanks for sharing your vision. I think Mr. Will makes a good point in his previous reaction that people don t know how to push themselves.
ReplyDeleteI'm still stuck in that mindset of following the gym rules.
It is like something terrible would happen if I would do more than three sets of an exercise.
Generations before us were tough strong men who worked manual labor and probably never heard of gym terms like perfect form or range of motion.
I like your vision of embracing the chaos and breaking the rules.
Maybe that is also a way to overcome internal psychological struggles.
Be that pioneer my dude! When you explore uncharted territories, there's no wrong way to go!
DeleteDavid, I work a job where I am on my feet most of the day and previously I worked manual labor/construction jobs. Your results may vary, but I always found that working out in the mornings before work helped. I would be warm and limber for most of the work day afterwards, which helped me move around at work. Whenever I trained after work, I would be more fatigued which sometimes caused my form/bracing to be subpar.
ReplyDeleteIt does somewhat amaze me what people worry about, and the degree to what they will worry about.
ReplyDeleteI mean, i totally get not knowing how to cook, as annadult. Having a mother who did the cooking and then going off to college with a meal plan meant i never had to learn until rather recently.
What i dont get though is why, when people reali,e they dont know how to cook, thwy would rather ask if chipotle 3x a day is healthy and then wonder if its ok to have a glass of whiskey at night. Like, bruh.
It blows my mind. We'll drink poison and shun eggs. We are a backwards species.
DeleteReally good post. And about the call of duty reference well... I started training 10 years ago at 16 years old when I was playing World of Warcraft and saw that I expended 500 hours in the Game and tought " well if I spend this time training at a gym I Will look like My character"
ReplyDeleteThanks so much man! And I've had those moments as well. RPGs are cruel tabulating your time like that.
Delete