I realize
this post I’m about to write is going to sound someone self-serving as a blog
writer, but it’s honestly something to just boggles my mind. First of all, I tend to be one of the biggest
advocates of just getting in the weightroom and slinging iron, and I tend to
decry those that spend all of their time reading about training rather than
ACTUALLY training. That said, for the
love of god, if you’re going to READ about training, quit skimming the damn
material and actually READ IT. Word for
word; every word, without question. The
fact I even have to say this is mind blowing.
Why are there so many people skimming the material?!
Apparently this was the original kindle prototype
Here’s the
thing; if you’re reading about training, I imagine your intent is to take what
you learn from your reading and apply it to your training for your own
benefit. It’s not an unreasonable
assumption at least. If this is true, wouldn’t
you want to have the clearest understanding of the material you are reading to
make sure that you are implementing the information in the most correct manner possible? Why would you want to just go running off,
half-cocked, unaware and poorly informed?
Especially on an endeavor you intend to spend years, if not DECADES
pursuing? Wouldn’t you want to make sure
you were fully informed before you invested so much time and energy?
It would be
like skimming a Spanish textbook before selling all your worldly goods and
moving to Mexico City. Wouldn’t you rather
have fluency? Before heading out to live
into the woods for 4 years, wouldn’t you want to read every single word of your
survival manual? Wouldn’t you want to
have it memorized, just in case you needed to go off memory? In any other situation where your success and
survival is incumbent upon the knowledge you’ve acquired, you would dutifully
take the time to read every word, memorize every nuance, and master every
corner of the material, but for lifting people can’t even be bothered to read
all 400 words in a 400 word article?
What is this madness?
Let's be honest; it's not like these folks are going to be writing at a super challenging level
Don’t
believe that this is some sort of hyperbole; that I’m off here tilting at
windmills. I’ve witnessed this firsthand
on numerous occasions, to the point that it aggravated me enough to need to
write this. I’m a big fan of linking the
Jim Wendler “Building the Monolith” workout whenever someone is looking for
something challenging to build strength and size, primarily because it’s a
great training protocol, but also because it’s an effective reading test. If someone tells me it’s only a 3 day a week
program, I know they skimmed, because it lays out 6 days a week of
training. If someone tells me the diet
is 4000 calories, I know they skimmed, because Jim only mandates a dozen eggs
and 1.5lbs of ground beef. If someone
asks if cardio is ok, I know they skimmed, because that’s all included in the
program. Basically, I know how dedicated
that person is based on how dutifully they bothered to read the article. If they can’t take the time to read 500
words, I don’t have the time to help them.
And that’s
the thing; it’s not a huge undertaking to read that article. I’ve read thousands of pages over the span of
my training, primarily because I’m a lifting nerd and I used to find reading
about this stuff super fascinating before it all started sounding the
same. But it took reading those
thousands of pages to get there. Meanwhile,
you can read only 275 pages of 5/3/1 Forever and know EVERYTHING you need to
know about how to program for the rest of your life…and people STILL won’t do
it. And these are people who PAID $40
for the book…plus shipping. Why would
you spend so much money on a book you DON’T read? What is this insanity?
SuperTraining, 5/3/1, Westside Book of Methods, correct me if I'm being incorrect
I just have
to wonder; what are these people DOING with all this extra time they save by
skimming? Because, from my observations,
they aren’t spending that extra time training.
Or eating. Or cooking. Or sleeping.
Or recovering. Or doing ANYTHING
that is actually furthering themselves to their alleged goal. And don’t get me wrong; I get that we all
have differing priorities, and not everyone is as obsessed with training as I
am. But that’s the thing; why are these
folks reading about training at ALL in the first place if they’re not going to
dedicate the necessary time and effort to read WELL? I have other hobbies that are just time wasters
for me, but as a result I don’t put any effort into researching them; I just go
and do them. And honestly even THAT
approach is going to better someone more than using HALF a plan to get
there. When you have a full plan, you
are on a set path for success. When you
have no plan, your victory is inconsequential, as you’re just here to have
fun. But what the hell do you get with
part of a good plan? Especially if it’s
not even the RIGHT part of that plan?
And WHEN you
read, TRY to get into the headspace of the author before you start. I find many trainees will have the conclusion
to an article in their head before they even start, and the bias in turn colors
the information they receive. The 5x5
crowd will find a way for Louie Simmons to justify Stronglifts, the HIT Jedis
will explain how “SuperTraining” confirms everything Arthur Jones ever wrote,
etc etc. It does you no good to approach
the text in the hopes that it CONFIRMS what you know; hope that what you read
turns everything you knew on its head.
How awesome would it be if it turned out you were wrong this whole time
and that success was now readily available for you? You finally FOUND it!
No. That said, if you've been skimming my blog this whole time, you might be led to believe otherwise
Set aside
the time to give the author their due.
They worked hard to write all those words; the least you can do is read
them all. And for those of you that
skimmed this post, if nothing else, I applaud your sense of irony.
What did you find most useful about 5/3/1 Forever? I'm still glad I bought it but after first reading, I didn't get much more out of it than what I already had in Beyond. Maybe part of this is a matter of where I'm at training-wise--25 and no complications--and some of the more detailed and complicated stuff will become useful in the future. A lot of it read to me like good possible variations/ideas but nothing that really changed the way I look at training. Curious to hear if you're implementing anything from it.
ReplyDeleteWR
MOST useful about 5/3/1 Forever is that it's basically a one stop shopping book for all things 5/3/1. No more having to scour the web for bits and pieces of ideas that Jim released on his private forum, blog and t-nation at various different times.
DeleteI really dug his explanation of the 20% to 50% rule for conditioning. The 7th week protocol was pretty nifty. I also liked the leaders and anchors paradigm released, as it allowed me a better understanding of how and why to implement the 5s progression.
All that said, I have no plans to immediately implement anything from it, simply because what I'm doing is working. However, I think I'm just about to reach the end of what I can get out of pressing, and that might require a different approach.
Yeah, I'm with you there. Limited immediate utility, decent long-term utility.
DeleteMy guess is the people who skim are looking for that magic bullet, because the actual magic bullet -- dedication and consistency -- is just too much work for most people.
ReplyDeleteWhat I never understood was all the people in fhe gym doing things and not carrying around a notebook for log keeping.
I'll say I've never actually carried a notebok around for logkeeping in the gym. No way I could keep decent handwriting while training, and calming tdown enough to be able to write would take too long. But I DO make sure to write things down after the workout is over.
DeleteThat's fair. You have a better memory than me.
ReplyDeleteI can't help but think that with many trainees the problem is that they simply can't conceive lifting and lifting culture as something they could be invested in learning about or to understand. They only want the useful bits, which should be readily available after a casual skim anyway.
ReplyDeleteFor many among the unliterate hordes in /r/gym, /r/fitness and /r/gainit, lifting is about fulfilling one neurotic fantasy or another: if only had I more free time, if only were I swole, if only had I perfect form, I could finally ask out the girl of my dreams, I could command the respect of my peers, I could finally feel good about my body, I could be immune to injury. It's not setting up oneself for the possible, yet uncertain, physical flourishing that is at stake here, it's fulfilling that one condition that's the sole remaining barrier between them and their happiness. They skim because that's exactly how one would go about answering a cloze test question efficiently. They don't want to author their own story, the skill of which partly comes from reading many stories well, since they have it already all written out in their heads, save for one solid plot twist that once and for all justifies and redeems the dork in the first act as someone who was cool all along.
It's simply inconceivable that assumptions like these could be faulty and since among the hordes respect for discipline (both as a personal quality and physical training as a field), critical thinking skills, patience to go beyond skimming and physical prowess are lacking, they can't see contradictions between their beliefs and what success has demanded out of successful trainees. Thus they are doomed to remain prisoners of their own echo chamber in which they are comfortably entitled to results and all that is entailed by them. And if the results are lacking in comparison to others, the order and law is restored by noting how others are enjoying the illegal tailwinds of genetics, steroids, willingness to wake up early, eating a boring diet, starting young, daring to sweat and being assertive enough to ask to work in.
This was incredibly well thought out. Thanks for putting it out there. Absolutely bails it.
Delete