This post is
going to be an ultimate case of irony, because through it I’m going to discuss
how there is no need to spend so much effort discussing beginners, but this is
what I’ve been reduced to. And my
longtime readers/viewers will be fully aware that I have a rant video on
youtube wherein I discuss beginners as well, and, in fact, it was the very
FIRST rant video, and it even pre-dates this blog, so it goes to show just how
long this topic has been something I’ve discussed, so let’s already come to
terms with the fact I’m a fraud. But I’m
one fraud among many, because so many charlatans are preying on beginners in
order to fill their pockets and bolster their reputations. Fortunately for you, I write for free and my
reputation is equally as poor, so now I can just say whatever I want. And what I want to say is this: there’s no
need for beginners to spend so much time worrying about how to train.
It’s true:
it REALLY doesn’t need to be as complicated as people make it out to be. Why?
Because the beginner phase of training is INCREDIBLY short. We’re talking like 3 months. Oh, after 3 months you get to be an
intermediate? No: shut up with that
stupid internet stuff. This isn’t a role-playing
game: you didn’t level up. After 3
months, you’re simply NOT a beginner. It
just means you can take the training wheels off your bike now: it doesn’t mean
you’re ready to race motocross. And if
that analogy is a bit crazy for you, I’ll spell it out completely: after that 3
month period, you can stop doing beginner “programs” and start doing an ACTUAL
training program.
Before
things get even more stupid: yes, 3 months is just a ballpark figure. You may need a little more time, you may need
a little less. Ultimately though, the
super en vogue training programs for beginners (Starting Strength, Stronglifts,
and all the other 5 rep based linear progression programs) will eventually cap
out. They’re SUPPOSED to do that. They’re not meant to be run indefinitely. Their ENTIRE purpose is just to get a trainee
used to lifting and groove the motor patterns.
It’s why reps are kept low: so a beginner doesn’t generate so much
fatigue within a set that they start having form breakdown and end up grooving poor
technique. It’s why it has the trainee train
so frequently: they’re too weak to be able to generate enough fatigue during a
workout to require a significant amount of rest. And they use linear progression because the
beginner’s PROFICIENCY in the lift is increasing rapidly with each practice
session they engage in. They improve
their ability to move heavier weights, eventually reaching their REAL potential
at the end of the training program, at which point, they can start ACTUALLY
training. Because beginner “programs”
aren’t programs at all: they’re routines.
Oh boy, I
just became an elitist didn’t I? No: come
on: words mean things. A program, by
definition, has programMING in it. In
the absence of actual programming, you don’t have a program, you have a
routine. A routine is just something you
do regularly. You don’t have a teeth
brushing program (at least I hope you don’t): you have a routine. But a program is building toward something. It’s a series of interrelated activities and
mechanisms working together toward some sort of established end. In the world of lifting, a program contains a
progression model that includes some method of fatigue management (whether it
be scheduled deloads, implementation of REP/RIR, MRV [yuck], deloads based around
performance metrics, etc etc), along with typically some sort of method of load
selection (percentage based off a training max/1rm, based off a daily max,
double progression) or possibly even progression outside of weights entirely,
based around things like rest times or bar speed. It’s true: a beginner doesn’t need any of
this stuff at first; they can just spend their first few months working the
movements and adding weight to the bar each time, BUT once they’re done with
that, they’re far better served getting onto an actual programming vs “milking
their beginner gains”.
Because now
we get to discuss the people out there trying to make a buck off the
impressionable beginners. There are SO
many more books and media channels out there aimed at beginners vs experienced
athletes and it’s for 2 reasons. 1:
there are, at any given time, MORE beginners than experienced athletes out
there, so it’s a much bigger market to tap, a secondly, experienced athletes
are going to see through the crap many of these dudes peddle and know when
someone is blowing smoke. A dude with
sick abs on Instagram may be able to hoodwink someone that hasn’t played a
sport since 3rd grade, but anyone with some dedicated time under the
iron will know right quick when someone is full of crap. The unfortunate impact though is that the
professional charlatans have been able to cultivate a cult-of-personality among
beginners that self-perpetuates as they begin to recruit more among their
ranks, and suddenly there are widespread “beginner wars” as trainees who haven’t
even crested the elusive rank of “not beginner” fight to the death over which
beginner program is the best one. And
these dudes making money from beginners have it in their best interest to
convince them that they’re going to be beginners for a LONG time, and thus they
need to hang on the author’s every word to make sure that they make the
absolute most out of this most CRITICAL time in their young training careers.
This is a
short phase of life, and the decisions made during this time are going to be entirely
inconsequential. “Beginner gains” cannot
be wasted: that’s a silly internet thing.
When you start training, spend time learning how to do the movements well
and how to push yourself hard. If you
need a blueprint, check out Dave Tate’s “Education of a Powerlifter” and “Iron
Evolution Phase 9” (specifically “The Super Strength Soldier”), but otherwise,
get to the point where you don’t feel really stupid with a bar on your back or
in your hands, and then start doing some REAL programming. Or hell, just start with the real programming
from the get go. Lifting is a long game:
you measure in YEARS, not weeks. 10
years down the line, the dude that did Starting Strength for the first 3 months
isn’t going to look or perform any different from the dude that started with
5/3/1. The only dude that’s going to
look like 10lbs of melted ice cream after 10 years is the dude that spent 10
years trying to make sure they were running the absolute most bestest beginner
program ever.
Don’t be
that beginner.
Great post, dude. When I first got into lifting, a friend made me a routine with shit ton of bodyweight and dumbbell work. For first two-three months I haven't touched a barbell. Worked really great and prepared me for a real program.
ReplyDeleteThanks man! That enthusiasm is so much more valuable than having the "best" plan. You develop a great base.
DeleteAnother great post mate. As a skinny kid who, although active, had no real baseline strength I wish I'd known at the start that beginner r programs were just there to realise what strength you had and help you learn the movements. If there's no strength there to begin with then no amount of time in SS will get you to respectable lifts.
ReplyDeleteThat, and this idea that I knew how to program better than someone who had actually achieved something.
Unfortunately we all buy our own bullshit but I wish someone had sat me down on my first day in the gym, told me to do SS for 3 months then just run 5/3/1. And taught me to eat for my training. And how to put some goddamn effort in.
Absolutely dude. It's why I say to never listen to the internet: It's all unsuccessful people telling other unsuccessful people how to be successful. It's always worth doing the exact OPPOSITE of what the echo chamber says.
DeleteI don’t think your reputation is low; that would be your popularity. People like you because you never try to sell anything.
ReplyDeleteThe way beginner programs work start to make sense now; however I am still making big gains squatting 3 times a week (doing Greg’s 3x beginner). I will keep at it until it does not work and keep increasing my cardio amount on off days.
Well I appreciate that sentiment dude. And there's nothing wrong with squatting 3x a week. Super Squats has you do that, and it's a fantastic program.
DeleteHonestly when i started lifting regularly i just did machine work with what was available in my apartment gym , leg press, pull downs , machine chest press , and bicep curls. Was this in anyway ideal , no , but i put on a ton of size and it got me into lifting. Now i got a coach and have a more "optimized" program and am making solid results, but i honestly think starting off with a routine that was all about getting the pump and feeling the burn helped me find that passion for lifting that i carry into my new more painful but effective routines. I think programming and exercises can be easily learned, i think finding that passion for getting bigger and stronger is the more important part.Plus as i proved , no matter how inexpertly your routine was put together, you show up 6 days a week and lift for an hour or so , something is bound to happen.
ReplyDeleteStarting off like that DEFINITELY set you up for success. Lots of different angles and different rep ranges build a broad base. Too many dudes want to specialize all too early.
DeleteI am definitely in year five of my beginner phase, lol. I'm very aware that I've been afflicted with a severe case of fuckarounditis. I guess it's all a matter of priority - or lack thereof - as you've said in a number of other posts.
ReplyDeleteRight now I'm not serious enough about lifting to do more than 30 minutes or so a day, so I've made my own minimalist routine (not a program) to keep me happy. I keep saying someday I'll get serious and dive into something like 5/3/1, but like I said... priorities. Perhaps as a first step I need to just buy the book and see if I can make it work with my limited time.
Absolutely worth buying the book dude. 5/3/1 Forever remains one of the best books I ever read on training.
Delete