Bringing
back some DnD again, because that seemed to be popular with my nerd-based
readers, and in a point of irony I intend to go against the nerd stereotype and
embrace ignorance. It’s amazing how, the
further along we get in training, the more we tend to forget the original
reason we started lifting in the first place.
At least for me, the goal was always to be big and strong. It’s so incredibly simple and easy to
grasp. I grew up watching Arnold in 80s
action flicks, Hulk Hogan’s 24” pythons as the WWF champion, Popeye beating up
Bluto with his ridiculous forearms after eating his spinach, etc, and I wanted
to be these men. I wanted to be so big
and strong that I was physically unstoppable.
At no point did I ever think to myself “I want to KNOW everything there
is to know about being big and strong”; it was “I want to BE big and
strong.” So why the hell did so many of
you abandon your goals in the hopes of being smart instead? Embrace the ogre here; be strong, not smart.
Hah! Different Ogre. But same point.
Seriously, I
don’t get you people. What is your
reward for being the smartest person in the room about lifting? Did you watch Arnold throw a phone booth in
“Commando” as a kid and think to yourself “Man, when I grow up, I want to COACH
someone to be able to do that”? Were you
watching Hulk Hogan tear off his shirt and thinking “One day, I’m going to
train a ton of wrestlers to be that strong”?
I can’t understand your ambitions.
What inspired you to give up on personally achieving these wondrous
feats of strength and to instead relegate yourself purely to possessing the
knowledge of HOW to achieve these things, rather than the sheer ability?
“Well how
can I achieve these things if I don’t KNOW how to get there?” Goddamn man, just how smart do you think Hulk
Hogan is? And I’m not saying that Terry
Bollea is an imbecile, but he’s certainly not winning any Nobel Prize. Arnold was born in the 40s, immediately post
WWII, in war torn Austrian (which, spoiler alert, they had LOST the war, so
things weren’t going so good over there); what sort of exercise science
information do you think he had access to?
Paul Anderson was a high school kid that wanted to get bigger for
football. Bob Peoples was a farmer. The Saxon Trio were a professional circus
act; goddamn CARNIES people. Somehow,
ALL of these people managed to figure out how to get big and strong without the
internet, 800 hours of research, exercise science degrees, a nutritional
program put together by MENSA, etc etc.
Why do YOU need all of this nonsense?
This looks SO stupid, but those women are digging it
This looks SO stupid, but those women are digging it
Is it,
perhaps, because intellect is so much more difficult to prove compared to
strength? You can go round and round
citing poorly performed studies with dumb control groups and stupid variables
(and really you’re only citing the abstract anyway) and then disprove someone
else’s study for having the same flaws as your own, and the first person to
resort to a logical fallacy “loses”, because you both took 1 semester of logic
in undergrad (or you googled “logical fallacies”) and learned that this was the
only way an argument can be wrong. You
can shout down someone else as a fanboy or for using “broscience” or get the
internet hivemind of your current forum to rally against the interloper and get
them banned and feel like you “won”. But
man, if you only deadlift 225 and another dude pulls 700…f**k, he’s stronger
than you. You can’t outangle him, use Instagram
filters, play with lighting, photoshop, etc etc; you just have to be at peace
that you are weaker than that person.
And it’s no fun losing, so why not pick battles where victory is far
more nebulous?
Stop picking
the easy battle here; you don’t get better at football by curb stomping a bunch
of 5th grade pop-warner players. You
settled for being smart because it was “easier” than being strong. Bring back that desire that was in you before
and endeavor to be the strongest guy in the argument, not the smartest. When someone cites 500 studies for how you’re
wrong, take solace in the fact that the person arguing with you deadlifts
400lbs less than you do. Be uninclined
to argue because you gain nothing from the experience. Have nothing to prove because it’s already
out there, ready to be verified. Be
accomplished enough that your word is enough to carry the weight of your
argument.
Technically, the kid on the right is usually superior technique right now
Technically, the kid on the right is usually superior technique right now
What does
this mean? It means those hours spent
pouring over obscure lifting journals and arguing with other lifting nerds are
hours better vested in training, eating, and planning how you will succeed the
next time you need to train and eat. “B-b-but
overtraining!” Hey, look at that; your big brain is getting in the way of
getting some big muscles. Embrace the
ogre and quit being so goddamn smart for a second. You are at severe risk of undertraining right
now, because you’ve already decided to limit yourself before you even
tried. Exercise science is a fledgling
field, and it’s basically in the process of currently discovering what we
already know, if that. There is still
much undiscovered wisdom which is deridingly called “broscience”, yet it
managed to WORK for decades. Spend more
time training, get in some daily workouts, or make your current workouts
longer, or figure out how to get more volume in your current workouts in less
time. When I ran Building the Monolith,
I spent a day planning out how I was going to run the program in less than an
hour, which was a day many would piss away arguing about MRV and whatever the
current fact-du-jour is. Spend those
hours cooking a week’s worth of food in a slow cooker and packing it so you can
just grab and go in the morning, rather than spending hours on the internet
lamenting about how you DON’T have time to eat, so could someone PLEASE tell
you about all the hidden foods out there that are cheap, fast, easy to make and
ALSO taste good. Spend that time grocery
shopping and finding good deals on cheap cuts of meat, spend it doing all that
conditioning that you’re neglecting, spend it pushing your limits so that you
can FIND them and THEN program around them, rather than waiting for someone to
FINALLY released the definitive study on all human limits.
Embrace the
ogre, go be strong, and beat some smart kid over the head with a club.
You're growing soft, Emevas. No squating on a bosu ball magic this time ? Haha.
ReplyDeleteI somehow fell into a similar trap. I started this journey to be big and strong, but nowadays I have a panic attack whenever I lose definition of half of my bottom ab. It takes some reflection to re-discover your inner child.
Your posts on willpower, brute force and ignorance etc are most inspiring.
I've been using that meme for so long I forget to include it at this point, haha.
DeleteIt's always good to remember your roots and look back when we get too far off course. Glad I've been able to help re-vector.
Great post as always. I know this trap all too well
ReplyDeleteMyself as well. Pretty much everything I lambast people for is something I've done.
DeleteGreat post. Currently having this mental battle right now with the assistance lifts on 531 Forever programs. Constantly trying to decide how to best choose the lift and what set rep combo. Internet has me doubting Jim know just how important they are and general guidelines must not be optimal. If I didn't have the internet I would just pick a move and do it, probably just how he inteded.
ReplyDeleteYou got it. All the way back to first edition Jim has said "it's assistance work, just do it"
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI mean, with Mike Israetel's MRV stuff, he's just saying: Do more until you can't, then take some time off to recover and let your body adapt, then do it again. Except with acronyms.
ReplyDeleteAnd honestly, he says you can't really find your MRV until you've pushed it too far and come off worse. Dude's got permanent pec issues because he threw lots of volume at his pec and had a major tear (if I remember correctly). So now he knows what too hard is. Most people don't squat til they puke then do more sets either.
He's acknowledged that his ideas have led to (pseudo)intellectual masturbation by beginners, resulting in undertraining. It is what it is.
I geniunely do not know who Mike is or what MRV is. I just see a lot of accomplished people talk about it. Before that, it was dynamic effort percentages and choked band vs non choked bands. There is always something new.
DeleteThat is kinda what you ( perhaps unknowingly ) sacrifice, though when following a programm. You let someone else come up with a pre determined arbitary idea of what your limit is. The good is he is probably more experienced, plus, it takes the guesswork out of the problem. The bad is ofc you won't be able to come up with your ''own'' programm very soon. Perhaps one should follow some less likely to hurt progress-principles instead and branch out from there.
Delete( captain obvious post, I know )
@Joe Kensei
DeleteWas this meant to be a reply? Seems a little different to the topic I raised.
The practical manifestation of what Mike's MRV stuff is for lifting is really simple - do more til you are unable to, then take a light period to recover. Repeat with more weight and/or reps.
How much "as much as you can do" is takes time to figure out, because it requires you to find "too much".
He also states that being unable to match last session could be due to accumulating fatigue, so at some point you need to push and be "stupid" to know whether or not it was or wasn't MRV.
Again - he's all about doing more til you can't, then resetting and doing it again. Not revolutionary, just with new words.
I imagine this kind of stuff may have originally been targeted more towards actual sports scientists to establish some common language and/or creating more questions, considering Mike's background as a professor.
To: yeah_nah
DeleteAh yes,I'm sorry,I was just talking generally,starting from the idea behind MRV(of what I understand of it) then went off in a tangent, (over-?)generalizing. I think I used the wrong term. In my above text, if you want, replace ''programme'' with ''specific weekly volume per muscle group''. The idea was, if you use a concept like Mike's MRV ( AKA simple common sense I guess )you can find your limit on your own ( thus balancing between optimal gains and overdoing the volume ) whereas if you blindly follow some coach's recommendation ''do X work/muscle group/week and don't change it'' you won't be finding your limit anytime soon.
I agree totally. I feel like some people need to "resign from the debating society" and just go lift weights. I have been reading your blog for a while. Your thoughts on not sweating the minor things and the value of "getting some" (experience) helped me break my analysis paralysis, pick a program, and just get under the barbell. So thank you!
ReplyDeleteI was wondering if you have ever written a post about your "essential library". I would interested in seeing a top ten of both your philosophy/theory must reads and training books. If you already have a post like this, please let me know, and I will comb it out of your archive. If not, I think I'm not the only one who would appreciate a look into the "Mythical Strength Library".
Anywho, great work as always!
Kari,
DeleteI've not specifically set out to do that. I've made mention of a few things in other posts, but never sat down to hammer that all out. I might make that a post in the near future; thanks for the idea!
Hey I know this is an old post, but did you ever hammer out that suggestd reading list?
DeleteTotally slipped off the radar, haha. Too many thoughts keep pushing it away. It'll have to happen someday.
DeleteThis is one of the main reasons I hired a coach. I don't think about lifting, there is a program I go do , I eat to the targets im supposed to eat at and the results come. I realized I am much better at executing than thinking , and that's where the results come from so I outsourced the thinking. Best decision I ever made, I much stronger much leaner much bigger and only read or watch videos on lifting for pure entertainment, my plan is the plan and I stick to the plan.
ReplyDeleteHell yeah dude! Being smart is cool, but the winners are simply those that can comply. You're nailing it.
Delete